Learning is a Journey

by Deb on May 18, 2010


Welcome to the May Teach/Learn Blogging Carnival, ‘Kids and Learning.’

The Teach/Learn Blogging Carnival hosted by Science@home is for anyone, because we are all teachers and learners.  This month our bloggers have come up with some wonderful suggestions for fun things to do with your kids, ways to help them learn and thoughts on what learning is.  Please read to the end to find links to other blogs, you might find a wonderful new blog to follow.

***

A common way of thinking about learning is ‘the empty vessel’ – children’s minds begin empty and parents or teachers pour knowledge in until they are filled.  Different children have larger or smaller vessels to allow them to learn more or less facts, and they may have wider or narrower necks to affect the speed of filling.  But overall the learners are passive accumulators of what the teachers choose to pour in.  When you put it like that it sounds extreme, but that’s the basis for a lot of early learning programmes promoted or marketed to parents.  Think of flashcards, baby and toddler DVDs, ‘Your child can read by two!’

My eldest daughter has just started preschool at 4 and I’m honestly shocked by the number of kids in her class who know all their shapes (including hexagons), numbers and letters.  One or two will have a natural interest in that sort of thing, but so many of them?  I’m pretty confident both with parenting and education and I’ve still had moments of questioning if I should have ‘taught’ her more before she started.  I’ve listened to other Mums of children about to start school asking what their children should know, I definitely understand the pressure and the worry that comes with wanting to do the right thing by our kids.  But if our answer is based on the empty vessel, is it a good answer?

An alternative view is that people construct their own learning, and it is inextricably linked to all the other elements around them including the other people, toys, weather – everything!  An easy way to think of it is that learning is a journey, from wherever you begin to a distant goal.  Imagine a journey you commonly make, perhaps driving to work.  At one level you do the same thing every day, but at another level every single journey is different.  You start at a different time, the traffic conditions and weather could be completely new, the cars you see on the way change.  When you get to work, you choose where to park (unless of course you have a dedicated bay!).  But that unique experience is how you got to work today.

Learning is a lot like that.  All our children are heading in the same direction, and may be going to the same place.  But every journey is different.  It is influenced by who is there and what they do along the way, and learners can make a lot of decisions to shape their own journey.  Thinking about learning in this way has huge implications for what we do with our children, so I’ll give you some questions to think about.

The first and most obvious – kids are learning all the time, not just when a teacher decides to pour something in!  What are your kids learning?

Who is going with your child on their journey and what influence do they have?  Who would you love to have go with them?

What are they taking along with them?  What lunch are you packing for the trip?  (Metaphorically!  I mean what skills or objects are you providing?)

What decisions can they make about their own journey?

There are some paths that are obviously dangerous or dead ends, and as experienced guides we can help steer our children, but there are also many, many safe paths.  Does it matter which one they take?

How much should we smooth the road?  If we smooth it too much, how will they learn to cope with roughness?  What obstacles can they tackle on their own, or with their friends?

The things they’ve learned are useful in that moment of their journey (like how to get over that cliff now it’s raining) so how will they be transferred to other contexts?  In other words, are they getting many different experiences in different contexts, to help them construct general ideas?  And the flipside, if they want to get over cliffs, reading about it ain’t gonna help.  If they want to learn to be scientists (for example :) ) don’t they need to act as scientists?  If they want to be authors, don’t they need to be authors?

So many questions might sound daunting, but for me it is very freeing.  I don’t have to worry about whether I have the right facts and if I’m pouring them in quickly enough.  All I have to do is travel along with my daughters, making sure they have food, water and rest and aren’t trying to abseil without a rope.  We can go where we please and explore every cave, climb any tree, sleep in a haystack or hop on a bus.  We can pick and choose who we are today, spending a day as a zookeeper or a fashion designer.

Travelling together, we create our own learning and act as who we want to be.

(For anyone with an interest in epistemology, this is based on the theory of situated cognition.  The article on Wikipedia is technical but has some good references.)

***

Teach/Learn Blogging Carnival
Visit Science@home if you are interested in participating in next month’s Teach/Learn carnival.  Please take the time to visit the other participants and see what they have to say:

Thanks for joining us! We hope to see you next month.

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Enjoy this article? Subscribe to the weekly newsletter to hear about them all. Or grab my RSS feed

{ 11 comments… read them below or add one }

PlanningQueen May 18, 2010 at 9:53 am

Loved this post Deb. And I have found that you can put two children on the same path and the outcome can be very different depending on the nature of the child. As a parent I have learned that sometimes you need to guide a child to path that may not be visible to them, but will allow them to flourish in their own right.
.-= PlanningQueen´s last blog ..10 Of The Best Kid Friendly Cafes In Melbourne =-.

Reply

Monique May 18, 2010 at 10:27 am

Such an interesting read. I totally agree about kids learning all the time, and that it can’t be all smooth sailing, they have to learn about the tough stuff too. Many thanks :-)
.-= Monique´s last blog ..5 Places to Teach the 5 Senses =-.

Reply

Catherine May 18, 2010 at 12:46 pm

Very interesting reading. I agree with you and I think that this is the best way to make sure that your children know how to think and how to find out things they want to know – which are after all very useful skills to have as an adult.
But reading Nicole’s comment, makes me think of the times when you need to give your child more support and a bit of a push to learn something that they feel scared about (swimming lessons is a case in point for me). I guess that is one of the bumps in the road.

Reply

amandab May 18, 2010 at 12:53 pm

Being one of 5 kids (the eldest!) I’ve always been aware of how different kids can be in how they learn and what strengths they have. I had a hard time when helping the others with their homework (my sister could not be convinced thT “Gallipoli” was an anti-British film, and my brother started a review of a play we had both seen with “Juliet was a chicky babe.” !!) because as a teenager you are not as open to other ways of seeing, or teaching.

I think, as a parent, your eyes are opened a lot wider, and you are more open to being lead to where the learning possibilities are. I am not going to sit there practicing writing of endless letter “a” ‘s until they come out right, but when it’s time to write a card I will show Princess how to write her name. I may not have known a dimetrodon from a polacanthus, but I am happy to read a few Jane Yolen stories and learn a few dinosaur names whilst reading a lovely story about good behaviour (two birds, one book if you get what I mean!).

Sometimes it surprises me the things we have learnt, and even the things we haven’t, but there is time for that, when Princess is ready and wants to learn it. Or, when she gets to school and has to learn it.
.-= amandab´s last blog ..B-I-N-G-O is the name of the game =-.

Reply

The Original SuperParent May 18, 2010 at 1:59 pm

I studied some of this when I was doing a course on knowledge management. Kids can get more knowledge as a vessel to be filled by a parent or teacher. I think they can also get knowledge by building up on other bits of knowledge – seeing an older child performing a more complex activity, for instance, and then taking it from there. Or they can build new knowledge by experimenting or exploring in a safe environment. In a company, sometimes it is wise to appoint an ‘owner’ of this particular knowledge – someone who will become a domain expert. I wonder if children in a class setting may benefit from taking responsibility for their bits of information collected and grow their collection in time. Cheers, Colin
.-= The Original SuperParent´s last blog ..Black Belt Learning Skills 101 =-.

Reply

Deb May 18, 2010 at 3:34 pm

Absolutely. As parents we have a special responsibility, and that’s why we need to journey with our children. We are the guides who know the way, or the big people who can see further or see a different path. And sometimes the way does need to be smoothed, it doesn’t always need to be left rough. It’s just a matter of being aware and asking yourself if you’re keeping a balance.

Reply

Miss Carly May 18, 2010 at 6:07 pm

It worries me when I have parents come in using the flash cards and then ask me to use them within my planning. It is the expectation that these parents have, that their children should be learning and the only way to learn is through flash card type learning. It is also frustrating that these companies market their products in such a way that some parents feel like they are not benefitting their child by not providing this type of learning.

Great post. Though I truly think that there needs to be more information in relation to play and interest-based play at that for parents to be able to access.
.-= Miss Carly´s last blog ..What’s In a Reflection =-.

Reply

Sarah May 18, 2010 at 11:44 pm

What a beautiful post! I love your analogy of a journey — it’s a great way to think of education. Your questions were so thought-provoking. Thanks for sharing!!
.-= Sarah´s last blog ..Don’t look now, but… you’re being watched =-.

Reply

Matt Klein May 23, 2010 at 10:13 am

Great post Deb. Love the comparison to the road trip. We emphasize that martial arts is not about the destination, but about the journey that builds your character.

Reply

mamapoekie May 23, 2010 at 7:16 pm

great post! I completely agree… It’s such a strange idea that adults should have to mold children, while they actually have so much inherent knowledge
.-= mamapoekie´s last blog ..Quote of the day =-.

Reply

Colin Wee June 4, 2010 at 11:19 am

I’ve just posted a follow up to my original post called a Child’s Perspective on Support Needed for Sport which is a guest post written by 5th Degree Karate instructor Matt Klein about the support needed by children from their parents. Check it out. Cheers, Colin
.-= Colin Wee´s last blog ..A Child’s Perspective on Support Needed for Sport =-.

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Previous post:

Next post: